GarageIntel

2016 Toyota Prius: problems, recalls and what it’s worth

5 recall campaigns to confirm with a dealer.

Before you buy Ask for the VIN and check it, then get a pre-purchase inspection.

Looking at a 2016 Toyota Prius for sale?

No VIN? Paste the ad for a fair-price check.

The full report adds this car’s market value and what to offer.

Known problems on the 2016 Toyota Prius

No generation-wide weak spot is flagged in GarageIntel’s research for this year and model. A specific car can still have its own problems, so get it inspected.

2016 Toyota Prius recalls

NHTSA lists 5 recall campaigns for the 2016 Toyota Prius. Repairs are free at a dealer for the brand, and a dealer can confirm by VIN which were already done.

2016 Toyota Prius safety investigations and free repairs

No open safety investigations.

Free repairs to ask about (warranty extensions):

3 more in the full VIN report.

A dealer for the brand can check these by VIN.

Source: NHTSA, Sep 24, 2026.

2016 Toyota Prius safety and fuel

5 of 5 starsNHTSA overall crash rating
52 mpgEPA combined
$1,250 a yearEPA fuel-cost estimate (15,000 miles a year)

From NHTSA’s crash tests and the EPA’s fueleconomy.gov.

What owners complain about

179 complaints filed with NHTSA for this year and model, about average.

Visibility & wipers24%
Electrical15%
Brakes13%
Engine & cooling11%
Throttle & speed control9%

Share of complaints that mention each area. One complaint can mention several.

What a 2016 Toyota Prius is worth

Rough trade-in values — roughly what a dealer would pay — by mileage, from published trade-in guides. Private sales and dealer prices run higher. For the exact car, add its VIN.

MileageTrade-in (rough)
40,000 mi$11,150
120,000 mi$9,800
160,000 mi$9,250
$0$5k$10k$15k40k mi120k mi160k mi40,000 miles: $11,150120,000 miles: $9,800160,000 miles: $9,250$11,150$9,250
Trade-in value by mileage

From new to now

New, a 2016 Toyota Prius started at about $24,200. At a typical 120,000 miles today it trades in for about $9,800 — roughly 60% less.

$0$10k$20k$30kNew2 yr4 yr6 yr8 yr10 yr12 yrAge (years old)2014 model, 12 yr old, ~144,000 mi: about $6,5342022 model, 4 yr old, ~48,000 mi: about $21,300New: $24,200 base priceNew $24,200This 2016 today, ~120,000 mi: about $9,800Now ~$9,800 (−60%)
This 2016Other model years today

Typical mileage = 12,000 miles a year; values between two published mileages are estimated in a straight line. “New” is the base price (cheapest version) as published, give or take destination fees; higher trims cost more.

Other Toyota Prius years

2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024

Looking at a 2016 Toyota Prius for sale?

No VIN? Paste the ad for a fair-price check.

The full report adds this car’s market value and what to offer.